How do Gotrax GXL Commuter vs. Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 stack up?

electric scooter comparison Gotrax GXL Commuter
Gotrax GXL Commuter
Source: scoot.london
electric scooter comparison Work's Electric Hollyburn P5
Work's Electric Hollyburn P5
Source: electricridereview.com

The electric scooters we have head to head here are the GXL Commuter, manufactured by Gotrax, versus the Hollyburn P5, manufactured by Work's Electric. We’ll take a deep dive into the specs of both brands, to help you decide which is better depending on your needs, and what you will mostly be using your electric scooter for.

Electric scooters are all about ease of use, versatility and convenience. They are designed to make urban commuting easy, which makes their weight one of the key characteristics to take into account.

The Gotrax GXL Commuter has a total weight of 26 lbs (34 kg), whereas the Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 has a total weight of 86 lbs (34 kg). Both models are quite heavy, neither is a good option for a commute where you’ll need to carry your scooter.

Equally important when considering the ease of your commute is the folded dimensions of the electric scooter, as these make a huge difference when transporting or storing the scooter. Gotrax GXL Commuter folds down to 44.0" x 6.0" x 15.0", and Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 folds down to 20.0" x 15.0" x 53.0".

Of course, convenience and portability is only one part of the puzzle. It is important to know how an electric scooter actually rides, and whether it will be able to handle your specific commute.

If your commute is a hilly one, then you’ll want to pay careful attention to the motor power, as this is key in getting you and your scooter up hills.

Gotrax GXL Commuter has a motor power of 250W, versus Work's Electric Hollyburn P5’s motor power of 4400W. Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 is good for hills, as it has enough power to take on any inclines you are likely to encounter.

Gotrax GXL Commuter has a top speed of 16 mi/hr (26 km/hr) versus a top speed of 35 mi/hr (56 km/hr) for Work's Electric Hollyburn P5. So if you are looking at long, flat stretches on your commute, and if speed is your thing, then Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 is the best choice.

When it comes to distance travelling, however, then the range of the electric scooter is going to be a key factor. Gotrax GXL Commuter has a range of 12 miles (19 km), while Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 has a range of 28 miles (45 km). If your commute is more than 20 miles (32 km), then Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 would be the better choice.

Battery life and recharge time are also important factors to take into account. Gotrax GXL Commuter has a battery capacity of 187whWh, and Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 has a capacity of 1207 Wh. Gotrax GXL Commuter will recharge fully from empty in 3-4 hours, and Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 will take 1.5 - 5 hours to fully recharge.

An electric scooter also needs to be able to support the weight of the rider. Gotrax GXL Commuter has a maximum rider weight of 220 lbs (34 kg), while Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 can support a maximum weight of 279 lbs (34 kg).

Now onto safety. Brakes are one of the most important safety features of an electric scooter, and may be the only difference between a safely completed journey and a trip to the emergency room. There are a number of different brake options available for electric scooters, all of which have their respective pros and cons.

Disc brakes have the best braking power, give excellent control and perform well in all conditions, although they do require maintenance, and are usually the most expensive. Foot brakes are lightweight, simple, and require no maintenance, but tend to perform poorly when compared to other types, are slower to activate and need a specific riding position. Drum brakes are also low maintenance, and better performing, particularly in wet conditions, but are heavier and complicated to disassemble.

Both electronic brakes and regenerative brakes add no extra weight at all, and require no maintenance, but again both types produce less effective braking performance, and can be prone to failure. Regenerative brakes can also fail to work when the battery is fully charged.

Gotrax GXL Commuter has Disc breaks, and Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 has Disc breaks.

When it comes to tires, there are two options, pneumatic or solid. Pneumatic tires are more comfortable, but can burst if punctured by glass, thorns or nails. Solid rubber tires however are far more durable (and puncture-proof) but will give a more bumpy ride.

Gotrax GXL Commuter has Pneumatic and Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 has Pneumatic.

Suspension can also help achieve a smoother ride, and although not all electric scooters come with suspension, many models come with front or rear suspension, or both. Gotrax GXL Commuter has None, and Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 has Both, making ${model_two} the comfier ride.

These days, plenty of electric scooters come with built-in lights. Options vary with lights available at both front and back, just front lights, or just rear lights. Gotrax GXL Commuter comes with front lights, and Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 comes with both lights, so Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 is suitable if driving after dark and safety are high priorities.

The final thing to keep in mind is the warranty. This protects you in the unlikely event of a fault with the electric scooter. Gotrax GXL Commuter comes with a 90 day limited warranty, and Work's Electric Hollyburn P5 comes with a 2 year battery and drive unit, 1 year material and workmanship warranty.

And there you have it, a full round up of Gotrax GXL Commuter Vs. Work's Electric Hollyburn P5. Hopefully this comparison gives you an idea of the relative strengths and weaknesses of Gotrax GXL Commuter and Work's Electric Hollyburn P5, and helps demonstrate which electric scooter will best suit your needs. Whichever scooter you pick, remember to always be safe, and have fun!

Side By Side Comparison Chart:
Gotrax GXL Commuter Work's Electric Hollyburn P5
Top Speed 16 mi/hr (26 km/hr) 35 mi/hr (56 km/hr)
Range 12 miles (19 km) 28 miles (45 km)
Weight 26 lbs (34 kg) 86 lbs (34 kg)
Rider Weight 220 lbs (34 kg) 279 lbs (34 kg)
Tire Size 8.5 inches 14.0 inches
Tire Type Pneumatic Pneumatic
Motor 250W 4400W
Brake Type Disc Disc
Battery (WH) 187whWh 1207 Wh
Recharge Time 3-4 hours 1.5 - 5 hours
Suspension None Both
Lights Front Lights Both Front & Rear
Frame Material Aluminum Aircraft grade aluminum and stainless steel
Standing Dimensions 43.8" x 17.0" x 42.0" 46.0" x 15.0" x 53.0"
Folded Dimensions 44.0" x 6.0" x 15.0" 20.0" x 15.0" x 53.0"